Economic forecasting: How’s the weather for YOU? [UPDATED]

stormclouds.jpg

Who ya gonna believe?

You could be forgiven for experiencing whiplash from the latest economic headlines:

Check that last headline again: Just when you think you’re getting a grip on how badly the economy’s doing, something — a good day on Wall Street, a favorable economic indicator, etc. — gets people wondering whether things aren’t quite that bad. It’s hard to know what to think about where the economy’s headed. But clearly . . . it ain’t that good.

Especially since I’m a business-news junkie, I have to be careful not to spend too much time reading the economic tea leaves. And given my interest in 20th century history, it would be fascinating to spend all day deciding whether I agree with the IMF that the current financial crisis is the worst since the Great Depression.

Ignore the forecasts; stick to the knitting instead.

But who cares? Sure, economists do, and regulators should. Talk about the chances of a recession with your friends over dinner, if it interests you. Button up your portfolios, if you haven’t already. (Although it’s a wee bit late, by this point.) But you know what? It’s not worth that much worry — not for most people.

I submit that most of us are better off more or less ignoring macroeconomic data as it applies to us personally. Sure, think about what it means in terms of your company’s strategic and tactical approaches. Lean times call for different measures — both offensive and defensive — according to what business you’re in, and according to what business function you perform. But does it genuinely matter to the marketers and product managers sitting around me here at Hoover’s World HQ whether we’re technically in a recession or not? No. It’s enough to know the basic trajectory and how it affects our customers.

And it’s still more important to serve customers well and to act on their feedback. I know I’m not telling you anything you don’t already know, but given the flood of financial reporting that threatens to drown us, it bears repeating: the macro-economy is usually nowhere near as important to your career as the quality of your relationships with your customers and the quality of your business execution from day to day.

Execute, execute, execute.

I’m in the same camp as Tom Peters when he says that getting your strategy right is a really important first 2% of business . . . but that the “other 98%” of execution is much more important, because that’s where your business actually stands or falls.

Great businesses have been started in every sort of economic weather. Somewhere, there’s an entrepreneur who’s starting a business that will be very successful despite current business conditions, or maybe even because of current business conditions. Heck, I have a buddy in Northern California whose real-estate business is expanding rapidly right now. He has more work than he can keep up with, even in one of the toughest geographic markets — and toughest periods — the real-estate business has ever faced. And what does my buddy do every day? Focuses on his business. Executes the details.

What YOU do to your business is more important than what the economy does.

My advice: Keep an eye on those storm clouds. Glance over those economic headlines. Batten down your financial hatches as necessary.

But then pull on a poncho and get to work.

~

Previously in this vein:

~

UPDATE, Thursday morning: Wordpress isn’t cooperating with me, so I’ll add here the comment I tried to add in response to dblwyo’s comment below:

Hi, Dave – Great to hear from you.

I don’t disagree with your point. Yes, folks need to be aware of what’s going on in their own industry and in the economy at large. For that matter, they need to understand the “weather” that’s affecting their company and their role within that company, since the two could easily diverge.

But I guess what I’m reacting to is the nonstop stream of media coverage that hyperventilates a la “Recession! Depression!! Meltdown!!!” or “Actually, an Obscure Indicator that Doesn’t Affect You Suggests It Might NOT Be a Recession”.

The trends we’re facing now in the economy have been building for a long time, as you rightly point out. NONE of this should come as a surprise. Okay, possible Bear Stearns folks weren’t AS aware as they should have been about the company’s periolous state, but we’re also talking about maybe the worst meltdown ever experienced by a major financial house in this country.

And again, many people will *worry* about this as they worry about rejiggering their personal stock portfolio from day to day, when in fact they would be better served to keep the economic weather and the state of the stock market in their peripheral vision, but to FOCUS on their own work.

Executing well in your own function, in other words, often covers a multitude of failings in macro-conditions.

~

(Photo by iowa_spirit_walker.)

Category: Economics, Management

If you liked this post, please consider subscribing to the RSS feed so you can receive future articles delivered to your feed reader.

4 Comments so far

dblwyo April 3rd, 2008 3:55 am

Tim – a good point but one which needs to be really thought about. It’s my experience that people and companies don’t pay enough attention to macro-issues, especially when they move from weather to landscape to tectonic changes. And as a result they enormously surprised when some clearly visible deep shift sneaks up on them. The metaphor that comes to mind here is frog-boiling. In this case the current economic situation was clearly visible last winter if you looked in the right places with the right tools. Those same tools allow us to filter the headlines into patterns. For example we can expect the economy to slow further and lower demand for capex which will greatly impact the tech industries. Another example – the Fed’s buyout of BSC (so-to-speak) saved the credit markets from collapse and thereby the economy. The recent legislative proposals represent a bigger change in how markets will function than at any time since the Great Depression.

May I suggest one needs to think Economy – Industry – Company – Job and build a dashboard mentality with monitors and indicators across the range. Another metaphor which is also a model – we’re rather like sailors who can’t go into the wind but must take as needed to get where we want to go. Subject to the wind, currents and so forth. Those currents are the result of multiple deep layers. If we just pay attention to what’s right in front of our nose we’re surprised by the storm. And if we escape the storm by not accounting for the currents we end up on the rocks.

If you’ll permit me to offer up three cases in point on dashboarding the mantra try these and see if you think I’m nuts:
Economic Review: http://tinyurl.com/2d43mj
Finance Industry: http://tinyurl.com/236hs7
Tech Industry: http://tinyurl.com/2a5ahj

There are a lot of BSC employees who were surprised who’re now walking the streets w/o savings, jobs or pensions. Just as there were a lot of WCOM and ENR employees who were surprised. In my view sad and unnecessary but typical.

dblwyo April 3rd, 2008 11:45 am

Tim – good points. Perhaps we’re converging an a central concept.

I certainly agree that one can spend too much time focused on the external news. The trick is to filter it into sensibility and set up a monitor toolkit that tells you what the tells are. Hence the dashboard label and the posts I pointed at. On the other hand too many people pay little or no attention to the externals.

To continue my sailing metaphor no sailore gets anywhere, or survives trouble, without understanding position and conditions. Hence charts, weather reports, etc. On the other hand those sailores who spend too much time wrapped up that technical minutia and take their minds off the sailing, which requires momento-to-moment SKILLED attention also gets into serious trouble. Often quickly and occasionally fatally.

The requirement is to balance “situational awareness” with fighting the moment-to-moment. The SA phrase comes from the fighter pilot community where it was literally a matter of life and death. And what they found was that good fighter pilots were deeply aware of the situation while simultaneously being fully into the moment.

[...] to me that during an incipient recession is a perfect time to focus on the [...]

[...] Economic forecasting: How’s the weather for YOU? [...]

Leave A Comment